Hi everyone and welcome to Inside the 23%: What CPG and Retail's Top Engagement Performers Do Differently. I'm Lisa Johnston, I'm VP of Content at CGT, the Path to Purchase Institute and Progressive Grocer and I'm very, very excited to welcome all of you here with us today. We are going to get started in just a couple of minutes while we wait for some more to join us. I just have to run through a few quick housekeeping items. OK, so first, while the materials in this webcast have been reviewed by our editorial team, the views of the speakers and the organization are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of our brands or EnsembleIQ. We want this webinar to be as interactive as possible. So please use the Q&A function to ask questions throughout the session. We're going to have plenty of time for them at the end. You can find that on the left side of your screen. If for some reason we don't get to your question, our speakers may follow up through email after the session concludes to answer any of them. That is also where you can share. If you're having a technical issue and you need to contact our webinar producer, Teresa, just drop it in there and she will help you out. If you have any other feedback about the webinar that you'd like to share, you can also just put it right in that section. Okay, so that's it for housekeeping. I'm really excited to get started today. So at a time when brands are investing very heavily in personalization and customer data and AI, of course, many are still struggling with that fundamental challenge that customers don't always experience engagement the way the brands think they do. So today's conversation is based on SAP's 2026 US Engagement Index. And so as part of this, we're going to learn about the engagement divide and we're gonna look at what the top performing brands retailers are doing and what you, our CPG brand, and retail leaders can do to create more connected, relevant, and valuable customer experiences. So, to help unpack the findings, I'm joined by Shady Ghattas and Sunny Neely from SAP, very excited to welcome them here today. So, I am going to turn it over to Shady to get us started and talk about the index. Awesome. Thanks everybody for taking the time to join us today during this webinar. So just a bit of context on what we'll do today. The first is what is the U.S. Engagement index that we sponsor every year? 2026 is the most comprehensive one yet. What is different about it is we engage both consumers and brands to get their perspective. And this year, we've engaged around 3,000 consumers on their perspective and 1,500 senior decision makers across CPG, retail, and four other major consumer facing industry verticals. The core finding that we're finding this year is really what we're calling the engagement divide. Really, we're getting vastly different answers from both brands and consumers on how the reality is. And that's what we wanna talk about today. We'll talk about, we'll drive this webinar in three core sections. The first part we're going to talk about the divide that we see. Where are the gaps in the data that are showing between the perceptions of brands and consumers? From there, we'll talk about the shifts that we need to make, the shifts in thinking, the shifts and how we operate. And then the third part, we will get very proactive with kind of the moves you can make tomorrow morning to start driving that shift that you need to do. The key highlight is when 78% of brands say that they're doing great on engagement, but only 37% of consumers agree, there's a problem, right? What we're doing as brands, but we think is good, that's not the definition our consumers are having about. What's also coming out very interesting as a takeaway from this is it's no longer just a marketing imperative. It's no longer marketing only. The expectations of consumers and way that we need to think about it becomes an enterprise-wide capability. So we'll talk about these examples. The first one I want to talk about is the first gap. And it's really around the connected experience versus the consumer recognition of these experiences. As I said, 78% of brands say that they're delivering these experiences, of only 37% agree. You can all think about experiences with a promotion, you've received a campaign, sometimes spent waiting on customer service, where internally customer service may report great first call resolution rate, but as a consumer I am frustrated because my answer wasn't really fulfilled. That 40% gap is actually quite disruptive. That's where you lose loyalty. That's where you lose market share. And as the good old adage says, you know, perception is reality, right? It doesn't matter what you think you're delivering. If your consumers don't agree, that's the one you have to work on. Why are they not seeing it? One of the realities still today, we see a lot of brands engaging on metrics that are internal. How many emails were open? How many, what's our first call resolution rate? What we're not measuring is, did I actually solve the problem of the consumer? We're solving, did my agent actually close the ticket in a certain amount of time? And that's part of where the gap is. Consumers, obviously we're, I don't care about open or not. Is this campaign relevant for me? Is it addressing a core problem or a core opportunity that I have? It's not the same questions we're answering. So how do we get on the same wavelength? And there's some pretty significant impacts of being able to connect the expectations of the consumer. Ferrara, for example, just by using the data underneath it to be able to understand that certain brands in their portfolio were more in line with certain customer segments. In one instance, gamers were able to really tweak their engagement very specifically towards these gamers and drive pretty significant triple-digit growth in those brands, just because they were speaking on the same wavelength of the core consumer segment that they cared about. Next, I'll hand it over to. Sunny, we'll talk about the second gap around emotional bond and understanding. Sunny, over to you. Listen, going on what Shady said, what a powerful storyline to talk about when we lead into our next gap here. I mean, Ferrara is a fantastic example of an emotional connection with consumers that really differentiates them from other candy choices. Think about how many candy choices are out there. And that's what the second gap is all about. I mean we're seeing in the marketplace, there's a misunderstanding. Brands say that they have a strong emotional connection with their consumers. But then 42% of those same consumers say that brands don't really even know who they are as a person. So this really gets sharper, I mean, when you start thinking about consumer products, right? These many consumer products categories don't have the kind of functional differentiation that other categories do. And you're talking about Coke versus Pepsi. Functionally fairly similar, it's those extrinsics, those emotional benefits that really define how the choice is going to be made. And when brands, you know, unfortunately overestimate, they, two problems come up when they aren't thinking about curating this emotional connection. First of all, retention will slip. I mean, eventually consumers are gonna try, they're gonna switch to others, they may. That may simply discontinue the category altogether. And that's actually going to drive up your cost of acquisition, because it's so much more expensive to acquire a new consumer than to retain one. So what's the fix? I mean, we're talking about how does marketing address the problem of emotional connection. Well, first of all, it's not quantity. It's quality, right? I mean you can do 100 more campaigns. But if you're not really thinking about the emotional bond that's created. With everyday touch points, you know, those consistent, meaningful engagements as opposed to trying to go for one big hero moment. I think that's where you're going to start seeing a lot of change and a lot of people that are able to close this gap. And the next gap I wanted to talk about is something a little bit more technical, but I think just as critical. AI, 80% of brands see AI as essential for attaining consumers in 2026. But look at how stark the difference is. 76% of those brands admit that they actually can't do the real-time optimization that they would like to do. This is where brands are really at war with themselves. The whole industry is telling us AI is critical. There's no question about that. It's in the headlines every day. But 3 quarters of consumers can't use it yet. And we know that the tools, there are many different AI tools that are available right now. But they're not good enough without first securing the data foundation that's underneath. And I think that's so clear across CPG and retail and other industries. 46% of enterprises can't access their data in real time. They're sitting on dark data, data that they've captured at probably a great expense, but they can't really activate against. So I think, that's the real message here in this gap. AI without the data foundation. It's just kind of an expensive demo, disconnected demo. And it's a trap that a lot of brands fall into. It's like they've bought the AI, but they haven't built the plumbing that's required to support it. Now, a customer example that comes to mind on this one is actually Nike. They really did a good job, I think, with building the data foundation to support their AI vision. So they would be among the 23% those who have that engagement maturity we're looking for. Basically, they didn't have, before they took this step, they were just using typical, you know, bash and blast emails. They weren't doing personalization. They weren't doing life cycle campaigns. They moved from zero to 10 life cycle campaigns in one year. That's where AI identifies where consumers are in the life cycle and actually delivers the message appropriately. So they were able to really close this AI gap that we're talking about. Two use cases that I thought were pretty interesting, you know, had to do with online to offline routing. If, look, if AI predicts a customer is more likely to shop in store. Then they'll get routed to the nearest Nike location. They won't try and close the close the sale within the commerce application. So I think it's really interesting. Obviously, I can predict if they prefer to shop online and and provide commerce offers as well. So there were really strong results here. One hundred and ten percent increase in revenue from automation, for example. Forty nine percent open rate left. So this is what AI looks like when you've got the correct infrastructure underneath. So let's talk a little bit more about, I think, an interesting question. Now, what are these 23%, these engagement maturity customers doing differently? And I guess I'll hand it back to Shady. Yeah, awesome. Thank you. So we define in the report, customer engagement maturity, 23% of the customers we surveyed are exhibiting this high maturity. And we define high maturity by the stage where data, intelligence, and action is connected across the systems, right? So it's about interconnection between the enterprise to connect the silos. We'll really look over the next few minutes at four major differences that that 23% does comparatively to the rest. And those differences actually can drive a lot of business value. Now, the first one is who owns the engagement. If we look at the, I'll call it the old world, is marketing owned the top of the funnel, customer service owned a part, you know, every function in the enterprise owned a part of the funnel. And that's not always optimal, right? The signals get crossed. And I can give a couple of really tactical examples. We've all been through this. You could think of the time you called the customer service because something was wrong with your order. When you don't have fully connected systems, marketing all they see is engagement. Hey, this customer made a call. And there's nothing more frustrated than you're receiving a promotion. Saying, hey, you've just called us, great. Do you want to buy more stuff when you're calling the customer service because of a bad experience? Maybe the more appropriate was, hey we're sorry we didn't really achieve up to our expectations. Maybe here's a 30% discount to help you stay loyal or a different tactic. I hate to bring back COVID experiences. None of us want to, we want to forget that one. But the most telling one for me of disconnected opportunities is when all the stores were closed, I was getting from a pretty prominent toy company back in the day a promotion for an article that can only be picked up in store. Now, if you talk about a disconnect between marketing and the other channels, there is a clear one there. An item that I clearly wanted, a toy playhouse I could put in the yard for my kids. That could not be delivered online, only picked up in store when the stores were closed. And that that just created a frustration where I moved away from that brand completely and went to other brands that were being a bit more effective with the time they had with me because I knew they weren't wasting my time with promotions that I couldn't act on. So that's a huge part of what the 23% do is really think through. How do I connect all of these things to be as relevant and contextual to a client, a consumer as they can be? Now, getting in the second shift is, we talked about this in the gaps, is how do we align how we actually measure what consumers value? And to that, I'll hand it back over to Sunny. And thanks, Shady. Yeah, so the second shift is about measurement. And here, there are, again, stark differences. There's the old world that's thinking in all these kind of marketing metrics like open rates and clicks and conversion rates. And then there's the new way of thinking. The new world, you can call it the current world, which is all about more business-oriented metrics, retention, loyalty, lifetime value, even crossing the chasm between marketing and finance. Some of these, what we're thought of as back office metrics are critical to the whole company be able to respond to consumers' needs. No, I mean, you know, look, opens and clicks that, you know, that tells you that your campaign got attention, but they're not going to tell you is whether that customer is going to keep buying, come back, refer to friends. And in a world where reacquisition costs, as I mentioned, very expensive, maybe five to seven times retention costs. It's simply the wrong metric to be to be following around. Um, top performers are redesigning their dashboards. Um, they're thinking about campaign performance, um, and not the headline I mean, you know that you should be thinking about retention repeat purchase rate and customer lifetime value in fact a quick litmus test. I mean stay Don't stop watching the webinar right now, but something you'll want to do right after it's over Take a litmus. Test is your team still measuring send volume and open rate? If so, you might be in the 77% we're talking about and you want to think about how you can modernize those metrics. A really interesting customer to think about on this one is actually a pretty good size optical retailer in the US called Now Optics. Between 2019 and 2022, they doubled their customer base. They grew almost 100%. But they realized that to continue growing. They weren't just going to be able to acquire customers forever. They need to start thinking about retention. And so they gave a lot. They create a lot of really interesting retention-specific journeys within their marketing. For example, no-show reactivation journeys for customers who cancel an appointment and don't show up. They put together a campaign around that. And then also prescription expiration. So obviously, you've got some type of doctor's prescription. And you let it expire. That's a great opportunity for a brand to reach back out to you. The results of just these two campaigns together around retention was a 65% increase year over year on churned customers one back. So this is a fantastic example of a company that's not just thinking about these kind of click through rates that marketers. You know, sort of exclusive exclusively marketers kind of in a vacuum can get excited about it's thinking about those transversal metrics like customer lifetime value that are going to impact the entire the entire company and lead to growth. So with that I'll hand it back to Shady for shift number three, which is all that data Shady. We can talk about these experiences and all in theory, but it's really hard to accomplish without a proper data structure. Let's just call it what it is. And the reality is for most of the customers out there, data is siloed. You might have your consumer data in one system, your marketing campaigns happening in another system, your customer service happening in a third system, loyalty happening somewhere else and so forth. And having different systems for the execution of this is one thing, but when the data is also siloed in each of these systems and not combined, it doesn't need to be perfect. But at least in some way, that becomes a huge problem. And the report states something I think is quite uncomfortable, is basically almost half of the companies we've surveyed can't access data in real time. Um, and again, a bit more than half are actually sitting on dark data that they haven't even activated. And you can all think in the companies you work for, or how much data actually sits on an Excel spreadsheet in someone's laptop, right? Or in a SharePoint at best. Really hard to execute on a engagement strategy. And if you even think towards the future, wherever it's going, how do I activate AI if you don't have a right data strategy? So it's not a, it's thought process. I think most companies we talk to understand the fundamentals we've talked about so far. The plumbing that is required to go there isn't set up in most companies. And that is, you know, when we're seeing these high maturity brands, again, they're not perfect. I wouldn't say there's a single company that has perfect data, but they're a lot better off on their data strategy and how they combine that data and really being able to get a more comprehensive view of the touch points with the consumer that matter in real time, right? So what it's really important is if I can get the insight in one week instead of one month, that changes dramatically on how I can engage and how quick I can respond to a consumer. So. After talking about the data problem, the next step is, well, okay, I have the data. What's the shift and how do we engage in personalization between these high maturity customers versus the rest? Sunny, back to you. Thanks Shetty. All right. So talking about personalization, a lot has changed here. Personalization in the past used to be extremely campaign based and it's moving toward life cycle and behavior based personalization. Now this obviously connects directly to data, you know, segmentation in the old world was kind of at the campaign level, you would run a campaign and then slightly have different versions. But in the new world, we really got to be thinking about the trigger isn't campaign data. It's more, it's about something the customer just did. Abandoned a car, hit a loyalty milestone, or made a complaint, and understanding exactly how that works and how to personalize based on those lifecycle changes. Now look. I'll be honest, if you're a CPG company here, you might be like, look, Sunny, I'm handcuffed to the retail calendar during the year. The retail calendar has certain windows and I've got to run campaigns. And that may be true. But thinking beyond just are you going to run a summer grilling campaign? If it's an urban population that lives in apartment buildings and doesn't have backyards, maybe the grilling campaign isn't right for them. There are other things you can personalize against. And I think, you know, same thing would go for fall football. If people are not sports fans or if they're adamant sports fans, you can create behavior-driven life cycle campaigns against those things that are relevant. So this is certainly true for consumer products companies. There may be a campaign schedule that you've got because of the retail calendar, but there's so much more you can do with personalization being life cycle and behavioral driven. And speaking of, you know, kind of these lifecycle brands, you know, a non grocery store example is of course, Gibson guitar, you know, in the in the You know, musical instruments business. I mean, Gibson's a great example of how they basically are using product affinity segments. They've been able to categorize different guitar buying customers into these different categories, leveraging AI to understand which personalization emails are gonna connect with each. And the customer feels, you know, that the brand really understands them. I mean that's the shift. It's when it stops being campaign, that's sort of a way of operating across every touchpoint. And another kind of a litmus test, I'd say, you know, the question to the leadership is if your team, if your leadership and your marketing team is still just saying to themselves, how did my campaign perform? That's a bad sign. That's old world thinking. They should be thinking more strategic questions. Where are we losing customers and why? You know, where can I find the next opportunity segment? That's sort of another proof point that you're moving into that 23% of more mature engagement insects customers. So I will now hand it back. We're talking, we've talked about these shifts that need to happen, but now I want to turn over to Shady and start thinking about how can we move in this direction of engagement maturity that all these different brands should be moving in. That this is the this is my favorite part of the webinar right is we talked about the problems we talked about you know what the best are doing but I'm uh I have a bias for action it's like okay so what what do we do about it and this is this section where we talk about it we'll talk about a few moves that you can do very tactically to start getting towards that right so now but now we get into resolution. And the first one is, you know, we've exposed a bunch of stuff. I think where a lot of clients get confused is, okay, I'm overwhelmed. What do I do? And really what I say is the way you eat an elephant is one bite at a time. Like pick one use case, right? Don't try to solve world hunger. Don't tried to solve for everything at once. Pick a use case. What's interesting in these cases is you don't need a big analysis. A lot of you will get in the room and you know your business is well enough. That instinctively you've got a pretty good hypothesis of, hey, here's one thing that if we do this, we're going to add value. So just focus on one use case. And it could be cart abandonment. It could be product affinity, whatever the use case is. And build around that. And I'd say, when I say most of our customers don't have perfect data. They don't, but what they've done is they figured out a use case and they said to deliver these use case, what are the data points and the data systems that actually matter to delivering this? And if you think of it, it's an 80-20 rule, right? There's a certain set of data points and systems that provide you disproportionate value. You can keep adding more and more and more, but there's diminishing returns for adding all of those other data points, right? So think about that use case that works. Get on that to go to go solve it, right? So not trying to fix the whole thing, pick one thing that makes sense, work with your finance team, work cross functionally to solve that unique problem. The second one, right, like how do we go from a very tactical get started to something a bit more scalable that touches the enterprise is about looking at how do I actually build a unified commerce, a unified profile so that I can scale. And now let Sunny talk about that one in a bit more depth. Yes, move number two, building a unified customer profile or consumer profile. I mean, this sounds obvious. I feel like we've been talking about this, the golden record, you know, so many different ways for years, but the data says it, believe it or not, it still isn't happening. Only about 38% of brands share engagement data across their CX team. So the rest are operating the separate views, you know the sales team or the customer service team have a different view of the data and it's not unified. Um You know, you can't skip this step because the unified data profile is the foundation for everything else. You know if you want to gain insights from customer service or maybe even trade promotion engagement and then build that together with your marketing outreach, this is where you need to start. The good news is, though, is you don't have, this is not, you know, the only way to get here or to start in this direction is not a multi-year, you know customer data platform CDP project. You know, you can start with the data you already have, consolidate it in one place, and then think about some next action logic on top of it. And that's where many of the 23% mature, you know engagement customers we're talking to have started. You know the moment you've got that profile, even a partial profile, You can start running the kinds of triggered and signal led campaigns that we've talked about. And so that will move us into move number three and I'll hand it over to Shady to talk about that one. Thanks for the intro. Signal led, right? Campaign led is still going to be an important part, right, like Father's Day is coming up. My wife, kids are getting some of these things. For sure, the typical stuff, right. Men's clothing, stores, barbecue, these will always be a fundamental part of the business. But more and more, the rest of the year, the signal is what's important, right and. It's still surprising in this report how many companies are not structured to do basic signal based campaigns like cart abandonment, for example, to be able to leverage it. So it's still for a lot of them, it's batch, it is very late, and it becomes unactionable. And I'd say this is becoming even more critical in the age of AI as the number of signals are increasing when you think about it. The number of signals that you are able to capture, to understand that I have a real demand, that I had urgency for that demand, will enable, I think, the leaders that have built that discipline and have built structure internally to take advantage more of it. Just think, for example, in AI tools, how much information consumers are sharing in their prompts about themselves. And how you can leverage those signals to be even more effective in how you do campaigns. If you're not set up to do signal-based actions, you're going to be left behind quite a bit. And again, I think we're just emerging in the AI-based signals. But if we think of just the basic things around cart abandonment, around reaching a new loyalty status and what that enables for me. You know, the signal is to drive me to do a specific action in a timely bound. There's probably no customer better than Molton Brown as an example of what they're doing, right? Large UK luxury, beauty and fragrance brand. They're doing single led across the lifecycle. Welcome series, birthday and so forth. The program runs in real time signals, not a batch job that will tell me, you know, congratulations, it's your birthday a week ahead of time or a week after. In real time. They're also using send time optimization. We all have very busy inboxes. And we know there's periods of the day where the open rates are a bit higher, right? If you catch me, if you send me an email in the middle of my workday, I'm probably not going to see it until late at night or tomorrow. And it might be buried underneath a bunch of other emails that will just get lost. If you hit me at the right time, there's a higher likelihood you're top of my email catching you when I'm actually paying attention. And you've got my full span of attention. And the results of doing this are pretty dramatic for a brand like that. 5X increase in revenue from email. Just think about that for a second. 20% uplift and repeat purchases. Getting consumers to repeat purchases, increasing by 10X the number of weekly subscribers. So getting, again, the consumers attached to your content strategy. And then 22% year-over-year conversion during key campaigns. These are all metrics any marketer would dream of being able to hit for the brands they work for. And it's really about having a proper signal-based campaign strategy. So disproportionate impacts on the brands, which this is my personal belief because nobody can predict the future. But with AI, these modes are just going to dramatically increase as we're able to capture more of these signals. Which brings us to the fourth move and we kind of hinted about it, right? This is not just a marketing thing. This is just a silo thing. It's about building the connection across the enterprise, all stages of the life cycle. And to talk about that move, again, I'll let Sunny close with that one. Yeah, thanks, Shady. Shady, you mentioned earlier who owns engagement. It's certainly not just marketing, right? You've got to make it a cross-functional discipline. And I think, unfortunately, you know, in many cases, only two in five decision makers believe that all the different departments are coordinated. Now, look, I mean, I think for marketers, one thing, it's hard to understand sometimes, but looking across all the different functions in company. There's so many other places that consumers touch the brand. Think about packaging, think about trade promotion, think about retail execution, the merchandising, the end caps, the lobby displays, et cetera, the things that are happening inside the store where so much of the... The purchasing still takes place. You know, when I worked for Ferrero a long time ago, we had an expression that the company is the brand. Like they're buying, you know, the supply chain, they're the coordination of the promotions just as much as they're buy the marketing and the product itself. And you know I think it's important here, you know beyond this kind of high level to look at. Specifically, are you sharing objectives across the departments, you know, do you just have kind of isolated marketing objectives? I mean, if so, the fix can be uncomfortable, but it's worth it. I mean think about shared goals, shared customer views across sales, service and operations to make this happen. That's what the top 23% are doing. You know, is there CMOs or in regular contact with the COOs, chief sales, and of course finance as well. It's not just about the marketing budget. So. I think a practical starting point here is, you know, pick one shared metric, maybe customer attention. That's an easy one for people to get their heads around. And really get marketing, service, operations, you, know, really to look at it weekly. Make it a project. You know, have a start and end date and look at the difference that you can make when you have all these different pieces working together. Now, I'll throw one other example in there. Back when I was working at Coke as managing Diet Coke. We did a dramatic packaging change. It was like unrecognizable from A to B packaging change, and it required a huge coordination, obviously marketing, traditional and digital marketing, trade promotion, in-store activation, even obviously all the marketing insights teams were monitoring various aspects of this, and it was very successful because we all worked together. And now you don't have that kind of dramatic packaging change or something like that, that brand repositioning that happens every day. But you don't t need to, you need to just pull those teams together around a metric. And really try and deliver. And I think you'll clearly see the difference that when you bring marketing out of that vacuum, you can really be a part of what we're calling the modern and the mature engagement team. And I that's the new mandate for success in this industry. So guys, really excited to share all this with you. I'm gonna hand it back to Lisa now for takeaways and Q&A. Okay, can you hear me now? Yeah. All right. Great. So sorry about that. So great, both. Thank you so much for that. Some great insights in there. Yes. I'm just going to do a quick recap and then encourage you to drop your questions in the chat. We've had some coming through. We're excited to answer them, but keep them coming. So yeah, just the four quick takeaways. So one, the engagement gap. It is real. Many brands think they're delivering those connected experiences, but customers don't often see it that way. So closing that gap, it really starts with understanding the customer reality, not just what you're seeing internally. Two, AI is not a shortcut. So the company's seeing the greatest impact from AI are the ones that they first invested in the data, the processes and that cross-functional alignment. Don't eat the elephant all in one bite. As was said, don't try to transform everything at once. The most successful companies, the ones who are winning are starting with that single, that high impact use case. They're proving value with it and then they're building the momentum from there. And then finally, last but not least, engagement isn't just a marketing responsibility. So you heard Sunny say that we can align teams around that metric. The strongest performers are treating this as a business-wide discipline. So bringing marketing together with sales, services, and operations around that shared view of the customer. So, okay, we can turn to some questions. Let's see, so here's one, someone is actually, they would like to know more about the title of the webinar. So they said the 23% in the webinar title is intriguing. Can you talk a little bit about what that figure represents and why it's significant for the CPG industry? Maybe we could jump back to that slide that shows the methodology for the maturity index. There you go, yep. So here, this should answer it. You can see that it's the high engagement maturity that has advanced adoption of integrated engagement technologies. They're doing connected data intelligence. And obviously we were trying to illustrate that more clearly with several examples throughout the webinar. But... You know, it's obviously directional. I mean, you know, there could be some high performers there may still be in the 63%. But I think the idea is you want to do this series of actions, many of which are pretty intuitive, based on changing, you know, aspects of the marketplace, the move to AI, the importance of data, the changing nature of personalization. And, you know, but there's another reason to hopefully have a look at the report, We'll be sending out the report. You can read through more of the data examples after the webinar. And this might be another one to read through after the webinar. Someone asked if the survey indicated if the brands that replied that AI is essential for retaining customers, whether they were divided between that meant more advertising on AI LLMs or it meant more improving data quality for AI LLMs. That was getting a bit granular. I mean, Shady, jump in there if you want to. I was thinking that, look, there are many different ways to leverage AI in marketing, right? Obviously, there's generative AI for dynamic, creative. There's marketing within AI for share of algorithm and things like that. I mean those are all emerging touch points with consumers, but I think they all, what we're trying to say is that however you're leveraging AI, You need to start with the right data, because when people don't use the correct data, you start seeing these unpredictable and sort of obviously, you know, I think you go into that problem we mentioned earlier in the webinar where people don t understand their consumers. They're displaying this sort of like automation-driven, automation-first mindset that it isn't starting with a deep understanding of the consumer, right? And whether that's LLMs or a generative AI, it's I think the data, starting with the data was the message. Yeah, I'd say like, I don't recall if the question specifically, if we've addressed this in the survey, I don't recall that detail, we'd have to go back into it. But I'll give you my perception just based on conversations and kind of the shift we're slowly seeing in consumers, right? And it, there is hype cycles that go up and down, like for a while, like we were thinking we're going to just open commerce and I think the. The AI vendors realize how hard checkout is. For those of you who work in commerce, know this, like payments and all that stuff is really hard. But fundamentally, the CP and retail industries are built on human emotion. They're built on, human beings making decisions. We spend all of this money to hit people's emotions, hit people desires, and get them to make choices. With AI it's actually bringing, it's changing that dynamic a bit because it's bringing a lot of rational thinking and programmatic thinking to decisions which human beings don't have. As much as we like to think we're smart and we're not, we're emotional beings. So I think it's very early to understand how advertising in AI will happen. But the one I keep talking to every executive about is when you think how consumers are prompting AI and the information that you share, right? So when you see people that have subscriptions to Claude or or ChatGPT, or whatever they are sharing their medical records and saying, you know, help, help build a workout plan around this, like ChatGPT now has all of this context. And the next thing they're asking is they're not asking. They're not going on a website and saying 12 pack Coke, right? They're saying stuff like, you know, I'm hosting my kids 10 year old birthday party. There's going to be six toddlers running around. I want to give them a healthy snack. By the way, I don't want this to turn into a mess in my house. Is your data equipped to answer, to feed that into an LLM in the right way, right? That's what keeps me up at night because the LLM is not getting emotional about the Coke brand or the Pepsi brand or, you know, it's going to look at data and try to answer that question as rationally as possible. It's going look at your health records that it already has and say, hey, you know what, based on your cholesterol, like the snack that you want to carry you through the afternoon should have these attributes that are healthy. Is your data able to answer that question? And those are the new signals that are coming up that I think are highly critical. And I think that that's what should keep a lot of executives up at Nike, because the marketing discipline, the trade promotion discipline was all built on human emotion. And this is the area where if you look at every step of the cycle, AI does not have emotion. AI uses hard math and rules to figure that out. I think like every technology before, the AI providers will figure out a way to monetize that and rank up and down. But fundamentally today is how do you provide the data to be found, right? Think of this as typical search engine optimization and Google, right, keyword. This is a bit more complex on your data structure. So maybe a long-winded answer, but hopefully that provides you a lot of food for thought on where the future is heading in my view. Great, great insight. We are getting some questions specifically about the study. I think we'll save those for your follow up. I encourage everyone who is watching. If you have, you know, if you want to get more granular into what was measured, definitely put them in the chat and they can follow up when this is closing, when this is concluded. I think we have time for just one last question. You know, you talked about keeping everyone up at night. Maybe we can send them off with just some actionable takeaways. So what is one move that you would share for a marketing leader they could make next Monday morning? That would really start moving the needle. What's your final words of advice? You know, I was thinking about this before, actually during the webinar, I mentioned a couple of things, you know, you should do right away. And, you know, it's not, I think, first of all, I think a little self-diagnosis is probably a great first step, you know, there were two different kind of litmus tests we mentioned. One is, Are you still measuring things like volume of emails and open rate? If not, if you are, you need to be thinking to the new measurements. And I think the other question was, are you campaign focused or are you more personalization and lifecycle focused? Really ask yourself those questions and think about what the implications would be if you want to move beyond this kind of like old world thinking. Ways of doing it. That would be, you know, a simple, simple homework, right? Guys, self-diagnosis and that hopefully will lead to some good action. Shady, any final thoughts? I'd say Monday morning, if you're a Head of Marketing, go for lunch with your Head of Service and just start connecting the dots. Pick one executive that you want to sit down to and align. How do we bring the business together? Again, the way to eat an elephant is one bite at a time. Take that first bite. Great. Well, definitely a great board to leave us with a great vision to leave us with. So I'm afraid that is all the time we have for today. So I have to go ahead and wrap things up. Sunny, Shady, I want to thank you so much for giving us your time, your subject matter expertise and insight into this report. I'd also like to thank SAP for sponsoring today's webinar. So just a reminder, a webinar recording will be available on demand shortly today on the PDPI, CGT and PG websites. You should receive an email about it. And so just finally, thank you to all of our attendees for giving us your time today. We hope you found it worthwhile, and keep a look out for more webinars from our brands. Have a great rest of your day. Thank you. Thank you, bye.
Inside the 23%: What CPG and Retail’s Top Engagement Performers Do Differently
Available On Demand | 45 minutes
About This Webinar:
Are your customers as engaged as you think?
While 78% of CPG and retail marketers believe they deliver connected, personalized experiences, only 37% of customers feel brands recognize them.
Drawing on findings from the U.S. Engagement Index Report, this webinar explores what the top 23% of CPG and retail engagement performers do differently.
Watch on demand to explore:
- Where your organization sits on the engagement maturity curve.
- How leading brands organize teams and use first-party data.
- Steps to improve engagement without waiting for a multi-year transformation.
- Why seemingly engaged customers may still leave.
Watch it now
Sunny Neely
Global Product Marketing Manager
Shady Ghattas
Global Head of Consumer Products
Lisa Johnston
VP of Content
Engage with the latest from the industry
Featured content
Real brands offering real customer engagement insights, including:
Context-aware engagement, powered by AI
Hi everyone and welcome to Inside the 23%: What CPG and Retail's Top Engagement Performers Do Differently. I'm Lisa Johnston, I'm VP of Content at CGT, the Path to Purchase Institute and Progressive Grocer and I'm very, very excited to welcome all of you here with us today. We are going to get started in just a couple of minutes while we wait for some more to join us. I just have to run through a few quick housekeeping items. OK, so first, while the materials in this webcast have been reviewed by our editorial team, the views of the speakers and the organization are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of our brands or EnsembleIQ. We want this webinar to be as interactive as possible. So please use the Q&A function to ask questions throughout the session. We're going to have plenty of time for them at the end. You can find that on the left side of your screen. If for some reason we don't get to your question, our speakers may follow up through email after the session concludes to answer any of them. That is also where you can share. If you're having a technical issue and you need to contact our webinar producer, Teresa, just drop it in there and she will help you out. If you have any other feedback about the webinar that you'd like to share, you can also just put it right in that section. Okay, so that's it for housekeeping. I'm really excited to get started today. So at a time when brands are investing very heavily in personalization and customer data and AI, of course, many are still struggling with that fundamental challenge that customers don't always experience engagement the way the brands think they do. So today's conversation is based on SAP's 2026 US Engagement Index. And so as part of this, we're going to learn about the engagement divide and we're gonna look at what the top performing brands retailers are doing and what you, our CPG brand, and retail leaders can do to create more connected, relevant, and valuable customer experiences. So, to help unpack the findings, I'm joined by Shady Ghattas and Sunny Neely from SAP, very excited to welcome them here today. So, I am going to turn it over to Shady to get us started and talk about the index. Awesome. Thanks everybody for taking the time to join us today during this webinar. So just a bit of context on what we'll do today. The first is what is the U.S. Engagement index that we sponsor every year? 2026 is the most comprehensive one yet. What is different about it is we engage both consumers and brands to get their perspective. And this year, we've engaged around 3,000 consumers on their perspective and 1,500 senior decision makers across CPG, retail, and four other major consumer facing industry verticals. The core finding that we're finding this year is really what we're calling the engagement divide. Really, we're getting vastly different answers from both brands and consumers on how the reality is. And that's what we wanna talk about today. We'll talk about, we'll drive this webinar in three core sections. The first part we're going to talk about the divide that we see. Where are the gaps in the data that are showing between the perceptions of brands and consumers? From there, we'll talk about the shifts that we need to make, the shifts in thinking, the shifts and how we operate. And then the third part, we will get very proactive with kind of the moves you can make tomorrow morning to start driving that shift that you need to do. The key highlight is when 78% of brands say that they're doing great on engagement, but only 37% of consumers agree, there's a problem, right? What we're doing as brands, but we think is good, that's not the definition our consumers are having about. What's also coming out very interesting as a takeaway from this is it's no longer just a marketing imperative. It's no longer marketing only. The expectations of consumers and way that we need to think about it becomes an enterprise-wide capability. So we'll talk about these examples. The first one I want to talk about is the first gap. And it's really around the connected experience versus the consumer recognition of these experiences. As I said, 78% of brands say that they're delivering these experiences, of only 37% agree. You can all think about experiences with a promotion, you've received a campaign, sometimes spent waiting on customer service, where internally customer service may report great first call resolution rate, but as a consumer I am frustrated because my answer wasn't really fulfilled. That 40% gap is actually quite disruptive. That's where you lose loyalty. That's where you lose market share. And as the good old adage says, you know, perception is reality, right? It doesn't matter what you think you're delivering. If your consumers don't agree, that's the one you have to work on. Why are they not seeing it? One of the realities still today, we see a lot of brands engaging on metrics that are internal. How many emails were open? How many, what's our first call resolution rate? What we're not measuring is, did I actually solve the problem of the consumer? We're solving, did my agent actually close the ticket in a certain amount of time? And that's part of where the gap is. Consumers, obviously we're, I don't care about open or not. Is this campaign relevant for me? Is it addressing a core problem or a core opportunity that I have? It's not the same questions we're answering. So how do we get on the same wavelength? And there's some pretty significant impacts of being able to connect the expectations of the consumer. Ferrara, for example, just by using the data underneath it to be able to understand that certain brands in their portfolio were more in line with certain customer segments. In one instance, gamers were able to really tweak their engagement very specifically towards these gamers and drive pretty significant triple-digit growth in those brands, just because they were speaking on the same wavelength of the core consumer segment that they cared about. Next, I'll hand it over to. Sunny, we'll talk about the second gap around emotional bond and understanding. Sunny, over to you. Listen, going on what Shady said, what a powerful storyline to talk about when we lead into our next gap here. I mean, Ferrara is a fantastic example of an emotional connection with consumers that really differentiates them from other candy choices. Think about how many candy choices are out there. And that's what the second gap is all about. I mean we're seeing in the marketplace, there's a misunderstanding. Brands say that they have a strong emotional connection with their consumers. But then 42% of those same consumers say that brands don't really even know who they are as a person. So this really gets sharper, I mean, when you start thinking about consumer products, right? These many consumer products categories don't have the kind of functional differentiation that other categories do. And you're talking about Coke versus Pepsi. Functionally fairly similar, it's those extrinsics, those emotional benefits that really define how the choice is going to be made. And when brands, you know, unfortunately overestimate, they, two problems come up when they aren't thinking about curating this emotional connection. First of all, retention will slip. I mean, eventually consumers are gonna try, they're gonna switch to others, they may. That may simply discontinue the category altogether. And that's actually going to drive up your cost of acquisition, because it's so much more expensive to acquire a new consumer than to retain one. So what's the fix? I mean, we're talking about how does marketing address the problem of emotional connection. Well, first of all, it's not quantity. It's quality, right? I mean you can do 100 more campaigns. But if you're not really thinking about the emotional bond that's created. With everyday touch points, you know, those consistent, meaningful engagements as opposed to trying to go for one big hero moment. I think that's where you're going to start seeing a lot of change and a lot of people that are able to close this gap. And the next gap I wanted to talk about is something a little bit more technical, but I think just as critical. AI, 80% of brands see AI as essential for attaining consumers in 2026. But look at how stark the difference is. 76% of those brands admit that they actually can't do the real-time optimization that they would like to do. This is where brands are really at war with themselves. The whole industry is telling us AI is critical. There's no question about that. It's in the headlines every day. But 3 quarters of consumers can't use it yet. And we know that the tools, there are many different AI tools that are available right now. But they're not good enough without first securing the data foundation that's underneath. And I think that's so clear across CPG and retail and other industries. 46% of enterprises can't access their data in real time. They're sitting on dark data, data that they've captured at probably a great expense, but they can't really activate against. So I think, that's the real message here in this gap. AI without the data foundation. It's just kind of an expensive demo, disconnected demo. And it's a trap that a lot of brands fall into. It's like they've bought the AI, but they haven't built the plumbing that's required to support it. Now, a customer example that comes to mind on this one is actually Nike. They really did a good job, I think, with building the data foundation to support their AI vision. So they would be among the 23% those who have that engagement maturity we're looking for. Basically, they didn't have, before they took this step, they were just using typical, you know, bash and blast emails. They weren't doing personalization. They weren't doing life cycle campaigns. They moved from zero to 10 life cycle campaigns in one year. That's where AI identifies where consumers are in the life cycle and actually delivers the message appropriately. So they were able to really close this AI gap that we're talking about. Two use cases that I thought were pretty interesting, you know, had to do with online to offline routing. If, look, if AI predicts a customer is more likely to shop in store. Then they'll get routed to the nearest Nike location. They won't try and close the close the sale within the commerce application. So I think it's really interesting. Obviously, I can predict if they prefer to shop online and and provide commerce offers as well. So there were really strong results here. One hundred and ten percent increase in revenue from automation, for example. Forty nine percent open rate left. So this is what AI looks like when you've got the correct infrastructure underneath. So let's talk a little bit more about, I think, an interesting question. Now, what are these 23%, these engagement maturity customers doing differently? And I guess I'll hand it back to Shady. Yeah, awesome. Thank you. So we define in the report, customer engagement maturity, 23% of the customers we surveyed are exhibiting this high maturity. And we define high maturity by the stage where data, intelligence, and action is connected across the systems, right? So it's about interconnection between the enterprise to connect the silos. We'll really look over the next few minutes at four major differences that that 23% does comparatively to the rest. And those differences actually can drive a lot of business value. Now, the first one is who owns the engagement. If we look at the, I'll call it the old world, is marketing owned the top of the funnel, customer service owned a part, you know, every function in the enterprise owned a part of the funnel. And that's not always optimal, right? The signals get crossed. And I can give a couple of really tactical examples. We've all been through this. You could think of the time you called the customer service because something was wrong with your order. When you don't have fully connected systems, marketing all they see is engagement. Hey, this customer made a call. And there's nothing more frustrated than you're receiving a promotion. Saying, hey, you've just called us, great. Do you want to buy more stuff when you're calling the customer service because of a bad experience? Maybe the more appropriate was, hey we're sorry we didn't really achieve up to our expectations. Maybe here's a 30% discount to help you stay loyal or a different tactic. I hate to bring back COVID experiences. None of us want to, we want to forget that one. But the most telling one for me of disconnected opportunities is when all the stores were closed, I was getting from a pretty prominent toy company back in the day a promotion for an article that can only be picked up in store. Now, if you talk about a disconnect between marketing and the other channels, there is a clear one there. An item that I clearly wanted, a toy playhouse I could put in the yard for my kids. That could not be delivered online, only picked up in store when the stores were closed. And that that just created a frustration where I moved away from that brand completely and went to other brands that were being a bit more effective with the time they had with me because I knew they weren't wasting my time with promotions that I couldn't act on. So that's a huge part of what the 23% do is really think through. How do I connect all of these things to be as relevant and contextual to a client, a consumer as they can be? Now, getting in the second shift is, we talked about this in the gaps, is how do we align how we actually measure what consumers value? And to that, I'll hand it back over to Sunny. And thanks, Shady. Yeah, so the second shift is about measurement. And here, there are, again, stark differences. There's the old world that's thinking in all these kind of marketing metrics like open rates and clicks and conversion rates. And then there's the new way of thinking. The new world, you can call it the current world, which is all about more business-oriented metrics, retention, loyalty, lifetime value, even crossing the chasm between marketing and finance. Some of these, what we're thought of as back office metrics are critical to the whole company be able to respond to consumers' needs. No, I mean, you know, look, opens and clicks that, you know, that tells you that your campaign got attention, but they're not going to tell you is whether that customer is going to keep buying, come back, refer to friends. And in a world where reacquisition costs, as I mentioned, very expensive, maybe five to seven times retention costs. It's simply the wrong metric to be to be following around. Um, top performers are redesigning their dashboards. Um, they're thinking about campaign performance, um, and not the headline I mean, you know that you should be thinking about retention repeat purchase rate and customer lifetime value in fact a quick litmus test. I mean stay Don't stop watching the webinar right now, but something you'll want to do right after it's over Take a litmus. Test is your team still measuring send volume and open rate? If so, you might be in the 77% we're talking about and you want to think about how you can modernize those metrics. A really interesting customer to think about on this one is actually a pretty good size optical retailer in the US called Now Optics. Between 2019 and 2022, they doubled their customer base. They grew almost 100%. But they realized that to continue growing. They weren't just going to be able to acquire customers forever. They need to start thinking about retention. And so they gave a lot. They create a lot of really interesting retention-specific journeys within their marketing. For example, no-show reactivation journeys for customers who cancel an appointment and don't show up. They put together a campaign around that. And then also prescription expiration. So obviously, you've got some type of doctor's prescription. And you let it expire. That's a great opportunity for a brand to reach back out to you. The results of just these two campaigns together around retention was a 65% increase year over year on churned customers one back. So this is a fantastic example of a company that's not just thinking about these kind of click through rates that marketers. You know, sort of exclusive exclusively marketers kind of in a vacuum can get excited about it's thinking about those transversal metrics like customer lifetime value that are going to impact the entire the entire company and lead to growth. So with that I'll hand it back to Shady for shift number three, which is all that data Shady. We can talk about these experiences and all in theory, but it's really hard to accomplish without a proper data structure. Let's just call it what it is. And the reality is for most of the customers out there, data is siloed. You might have your consumer data in one system, your marketing campaigns happening in another system, your customer service happening in a third system, loyalty happening somewhere else and so forth. And having different systems for the execution of this is one thing, but when the data is also siloed in each of these systems and not combined, it doesn't need to be perfect. But at least in some way, that becomes a huge problem. And the report states something I think is quite uncomfortable, is basically almost half of the companies we've surveyed can't access data in real time. Um, and again, a bit more than half are actually sitting on dark data that they haven't even activated. And you can all think in the companies you work for, or how much data actually sits on an Excel spreadsheet in someone's laptop, right? Or in a SharePoint at best. Really hard to execute on a engagement strategy. And if you even think towards the future, wherever it's going, how do I activate AI if you don't have a right data strategy? So it's not a, it's thought process. I think most companies we talk to understand the fundamentals we've talked about so far. The plumbing that is required to go there isn't set up in most companies. And that is, you know, when we're seeing these high maturity brands, again, they're not perfect. I wouldn't say there's a single company that has perfect data, but they're a lot better off on their data strategy and how they combine that data and really being able to get a more comprehensive view of the touch points with the consumer that matter in real time, right? So what it's really important is if I can get the insight in one week instead of one month, that changes dramatically on how I can engage and how quick I can respond to a consumer. So. After talking about the data problem, the next step is, well, okay, I have the data. What's the shift and how do we engage in personalization between these high maturity customers versus the rest? Sunny, back to you. Thanks Shetty. All right. So talking about personalization, a lot has changed here. Personalization in the past used to be extremely campaign based and it's moving toward life cycle and behavior based personalization. Now this obviously connects directly to data, you know, segmentation in the old world was kind of at the campaign level, you would run a campaign and then slightly have different versions. But in the new world, we really got to be thinking about the trigger isn't campaign data. It's more, it's about something the customer just did. Abandoned a car, hit a loyalty milestone, or made a complaint, and understanding exactly how that works and how to personalize based on those lifecycle changes. Now look. I'll be honest, if you're a CPG company here, you might be like, look, Sunny, I'm handcuffed to the retail calendar during the year. The retail calendar has certain windows and I've got to run campaigns. And that may be true. But thinking beyond just are you going to run a summer grilling campaign? If it's an urban population that lives in apartment buildings and doesn't have backyards, maybe the grilling campaign isn't right for them. There are other things you can personalize against. And I think, you know, same thing would go for fall football. If people are not sports fans or if they're adamant sports fans, you can create behavior-driven life cycle campaigns against those things that are relevant. So this is certainly true for consumer products companies. There may be a campaign schedule that you've got because of the retail calendar, but there's so much more you can do with personalization being life cycle and behavioral driven. And speaking of, you know, kind of these lifecycle brands, you know, a non grocery store example is of course, Gibson guitar, you know, in the in the You know, musical instruments business. I mean, Gibson's a great example of how they basically are using product affinity segments. They've been able to categorize different guitar buying customers into these different categories, leveraging AI to understand which personalization emails are gonna connect with each. And the customer feels, you know, that the brand really understands them. I mean that's the shift. It's when it stops being campaign, that's sort of a way of operating across every touchpoint. And another kind of a litmus test, I'd say, you know, the question to the leadership is if your team, if your leadership and your marketing team is still just saying to themselves, how did my campaign perform? That's a bad sign. That's old world thinking. They should be thinking more strategic questions. Where are we losing customers and why? You know, where can I find the next opportunity segment? That's sort of another proof point that you're moving into that 23% of more mature engagement insects customers. So I will now hand it back. We're talking, we've talked about these shifts that need to happen, but now I want to turn over to Shady and start thinking about how can we move in this direction of engagement maturity that all these different brands should be moving in. That this is the this is my favorite part of the webinar right is we talked about the problems we talked about you know what the best are doing but I'm uh I have a bias for action it's like okay so what what do we do about it and this is this section where we talk about it we'll talk about a few moves that you can do very tactically to start getting towards that right so now but now we get into resolution. And the first one is, you know, we've exposed a bunch of stuff. I think where a lot of clients get confused is, okay, I'm overwhelmed. What do I do? And really what I say is the way you eat an elephant is one bite at a time. Like pick one use case, right? Don't try to solve world hunger. Don't tried to solve for everything at once. Pick a use case. What's interesting in these cases is you don't need a big analysis. A lot of you will get in the room and you know your business is well enough. That instinctively you've got a pretty good hypothesis of, hey, here's one thing that if we do this, we're going to add value. So just focus on one use case. And it could be cart abandonment. It could be product affinity, whatever the use case is. And build around that. And I'd say, when I say most of our customers don't have perfect data. They don't, but what they've done is they figured out a use case and they said to deliver these use case, what are the data points and the data systems that actually matter to delivering this? And if you think of it, it's an 80-20 rule, right? There's a certain set of data points and systems that provide you disproportionate value. You can keep adding more and more and more, but there's diminishing returns for adding all of those other data points, right? So think about that use case that works. Get on that to go to go solve it, right? So not trying to fix the whole thing, pick one thing that makes sense, work with your finance team, work cross functionally to solve that unique problem. The second one, right, like how do we go from a very tactical get started to something a bit more scalable that touches the enterprise is about looking at how do I actually build a unified commerce, a unified profile so that I can scale. And now let Sunny talk about that one in a bit more depth. Yes, move number two, building a unified customer profile or consumer profile. I mean, this sounds obvious. I feel like we've been talking about this, the golden record, you know, so many different ways for years, but the data says it, believe it or not, it still isn't happening. Only about 38% of brands share engagement data across their CX team. So the rest are operating the separate views, you know the sales team or the customer service team have a different view of the data and it's not unified. Um You know, you can't skip this step because the unified data profile is the foundation for everything else. You know if you want to gain insights from customer service or maybe even trade promotion engagement and then build that together with your marketing outreach, this is where you need to start. The good news is, though, is you don't have, this is not, you know, the only way to get here or to start in this direction is not a multi-year, you know customer data platform CDP project. You know, you can start with the data you already have, consolidate it in one place, and then think about some next action logic on top of it. And that's where many of the 23% mature, you know engagement customers we're talking to have started. You know the moment you've got that profile, even a partial profile, You can start running the kinds of triggered and signal led campaigns that we've talked about. And so that will move us into move number three and I'll hand it over to Shady to talk about that one. Thanks for the intro. Signal led, right? Campaign led is still going to be an important part, right, like Father's Day is coming up. My wife, kids are getting some of these things. For sure, the typical stuff, right. Men's clothing, stores, barbecue, these will always be a fundamental part of the business. But more and more, the rest of the year, the signal is what's important, right and. It's still surprising in this report how many companies are not structured to do basic signal based campaigns like cart abandonment, for example, to be able to leverage it. So it's still for a lot of them, it's batch, it is very late, and it becomes unactionable. And I'd say this is becoming even more critical in the age of AI as the number of signals are increasing when you think about it. The number of signals that you are able to capture, to understand that I have a real demand, that I had urgency for that demand, will enable, I think, the leaders that have built that discipline and have built structure internally to take advantage more of it. Just think, for example, in AI tools, how much information consumers are sharing in their prompts about themselves. And how you can leverage those signals to be even more effective in how you do campaigns. If you're not set up to do signal-based actions, you're going to be left behind quite a bit. And again, I think we're just emerging in the AI-based signals. But if we think of just the basic things around cart abandonment, around reaching a new loyalty status and what that enables for me. You know, the signal is to drive me to do a specific action in a timely bound. There's probably no customer better than Molton Brown as an example of what they're doing, right? Large UK luxury, beauty and fragrance brand. They're doing single led across the lifecycle. Welcome series, birthday and so forth. The program runs in real time signals, not a batch job that will tell me, you know, congratulations, it's your birthday a week ahead of time or a week after. In real time. They're also using send time optimization. We all have very busy inboxes. And we know there's periods of the day where the open rates are a bit higher, right? If you catch me, if you send me an email in the middle of my workday, I'm probably not going to see it until late at night or tomorrow. And it might be buried underneath a bunch of other emails that will just get lost. If you hit me at the right time, there's a higher likelihood you're top of my email catching you when I'm actually paying attention. And you've got my full span of attention. And the results of doing this are pretty dramatic for a brand like that. 5X increase in revenue from email. Just think about that for a second. 20% uplift and repeat purchases. Getting consumers to repeat purchases, increasing by 10X the number of weekly subscribers. So getting, again, the consumers attached to your content strategy. And then 22% year-over-year conversion during key campaigns. These are all metrics any marketer would dream of being able to hit for the brands they work for. And it's really about having a proper signal-based campaign strategy. So disproportionate impacts on the brands, which this is my personal belief because nobody can predict the future. But with AI, these modes are just going to dramatically increase as we're able to capture more of these signals. Which brings us to the fourth move and we kind of hinted about it, right? This is not just a marketing thing. This is just a silo thing. It's about building the connection across the enterprise, all stages of the life cycle. And to talk about that move, again, I'll let Sunny close with that one. Yeah, thanks, Shady. Shady, you mentioned earlier who owns engagement. It's certainly not just marketing, right? You've got to make it a cross-functional discipline. And I think, unfortunately, you know, in many cases, only two in five decision makers believe that all the different departments are coordinated. Now, look, I mean, I think for marketers, one thing, it's hard to understand sometimes, but looking across all the different functions in company. There's so many other places that consumers touch the brand. Think about packaging, think about trade promotion, think about retail execution, the merchandising, the end caps, the lobby displays, et cetera, the things that are happening inside the store where so much of the... The purchasing still takes place. You know, when I worked for Ferrero a long time ago, we had an expression that the company is the brand. Like they're buying, you know, the supply chain, they're the coordination of the promotions just as much as they're buy the marketing and the product itself. And you know I think it's important here, you know beyond this kind of high level to look at. Specifically, are you sharing objectives across the departments, you know, do you just have kind of isolated marketing objectives? I mean, if so, the fix can be uncomfortable, but it's worth it. I mean think about shared goals, shared customer views across sales, service and operations to make this happen. That's what the top 23% are doing. You know, is there CMOs or in regular contact with the COOs, chief sales, and of course finance as well. It's not just about the marketing budget. So. I think a practical starting point here is, you know, pick one shared metric, maybe customer attention. That's an easy one for people to get their heads around. And really get marketing, service, operations, you, know, really to look at it weekly. Make it a project. You know, have a start and end date and look at the difference that you can make when you have all these different pieces working together. Now, I'll throw one other example in there. Back when I was working at Coke as managing Diet Coke. We did a dramatic packaging change. It was like unrecognizable from A to B packaging change, and it required a huge coordination, obviously marketing, traditional and digital marketing, trade promotion, in-store activation, even obviously all the marketing insights teams were monitoring various aspects of this, and it was very successful because we all worked together. And now you don't have that kind of dramatic packaging change or something like that, that brand repositioning that happens every day. But you don't t need to, you need to just pull those teams together around a metric. And really try and deliver. And I think you'll clearly see the difference that when you bring marketing out of that vacuum, you can really be a part of what we're calling the modern and the mature engagement team. And I that's the new mandate for success in this industry. So guys, really excited to share all this with you. I'm gonna hand it back to Lisa now for takeaways and Q&A. Okay, can you hear me now? Yeah. All right. Great. So sorry about that. So great, both. Thank you so much for that. Some great insights in there. Yes. I'm just going to do a quick recap and then encourage you to drop your questions in the chat. We've had some coming through. We're excited to answer them, but keep them coming. So yeah, just the four quick takeaways. So one, the engagement gap. It is real. Many brands think they're delivering those connected experiences, but customers don't often see it that way. So closing that gap, it really starts with understanding the customer reality, not just what you're seeing internally. Two, AI is not a shortcut. So the company's seeing the greatest impact from AI are the ones that they first invested in the data, the processes and that cross-functional alignment. Don't eat the elephant all in one bite. As was said, don't try to transform everything at once. The most successful companies, the ones who are winning are starting with that single, that high impact use case. They're proving value with it and then they're building the momentum from there. And then finally, last but not least, engagement isn't just a marketing responsibility. So you heard Sunny say that we can align teams around that metric. The strongest performers are treating this as a business-wide discipline. So bringing marketing together with sales, services, and operations around that shared view of the customer. So, okay, we can turn to some questions. Let's see, so here's one, someone is actually, they would like to know more about the title of the webinar. So they said the 23% in the webinar title is intriguing. Can you talk a little bit about what that figure represents and why it's significant for the CPG industry? Maybe we could jump back to that slide that shows the methodology for the maturity index. There you go, yep. So here, this should answer it. You can see that it's the high engagement maturity that has advanced adoption of integrated engagement technologies. They're doing connected data intelligence. And obviously we were trying to illustrate that more clearly with several examples throughout the webinar. But... You know, it's obviously directional. I mean, you know, there could be some high performers there may still be in the 63%. But I think the idea is you want to do this series of actions, many of which are pretty intuitive, based on changing, you know, aspects of the marketplace, the move to AI, the importance of data, the changing nature of personalization. And, you know, but there's another reason to hopefully have a look at the report, We'll be sending out the report. You can read through more of the data examples after the webinar. And this might be another one to read through after the webinar. Someone asked if the survey indicated if the brands that replied that AI is essential for retaining customers, whether they were divided between that meant more advertising on AI LLMs or it meant more improving data quality for AI LLMs. That was getting a bit granular. I mean, Shady, jump in there if you want to. I was thinking that, look, there are many different ways to leverage AI in marketing, right? Obviously, there's generative AI for dynamic, creative. There's marketing within AI for share of algorithm and things like that. I mean those are all emerging touch points with consumers, but I think they all, what we're trying to say is that however you're leveraging AI, You need to start with the right data, because when people don't use the correct data, you start seeing these unpredictable and sort of obviously, you know, I think you go into that problem we mentioned earlier in the webinar where people don t understand their consumers. They're displaying this sort of like automation-driven, automation-first mindset that it isn't starting with a deep understanding of the consumer, right? And whether that's LLMs or a generative AI, it's I think the data, starting with the data was the message. Yeah, I'd say like, I don't recall if the question specifically, if we've addressed this in the survey, I don't recall that detail, we'd have to go back into it. But I'll give you my perception just based on conversations and kind of the shift we're slowly seeing in consumers, right? And it, there is hype cycles that go up and down, like for a while, like we were thinking we're going to just open commerce and I think the. The AI vendors realize how hard checkout is. For those of you who work in commerce, know this, like payments and all that stuff is really hard. But fundamentally, the CP and retail industries are built on human emotion. They're built on, human beings making decisions. We spend all of this money to hit people's emotions, hit people desires, and get them to make choices. With AI it's actually bringing, it's changing that dynamic a bit because it's bringing a lot of rational thinking and programmatic thinking to decisions which human beings don't have. As much as we like to think we're smart and we're not, we're emotional beings. So I think it's very early to understand how advertising in AI will happen. But the one I keep talking to every executive about is when you think how consumers are prompting AI and the information that you share, right? So when you see people that have subscriptions to Claude or or ChatGPT, or whatever they are sharing their medical records and saying, you know, help, help build a workout plan around this, like ChatGPT now has all of this context. And the next thing they're asking is they're not asking. They're not going on a website and saying 12 pack Coke, right? They're saying stuff like, you know, I'm hosting my kids 10 year old birthday party. There's going to be six toddlers running around. I want to give them a healthy snack. By the way, I don't want this to turn into a mess in my house. Is your data equipped to answer, to feed that into an LLM in the right way, right? That's what keeps me up at night because the LLM is not getting emotional about the Coke brand or the Pepsi brand or, you know, it's going to look at data and try to answer that question as rationally as possible. It's going look at your health records that it already has and say, hey, you know what, based on your cholesterol, like the snack that you want to carry you through the afternoon should have these attributes that are healthy. Is your data able to answer that question? And those are the new signals that are coming up that I think are highly critical. And I think that that's what should keep a lot of executives up at Nike, because the marketing discipline, the trade promotion discipline was all built on human emotion. And this is the area where if you look at every step of the cycle, AI does not have emotion. AI uses hard math and rules to figure that out. I think like every technology before, the AI providers will figure out a way to monetize that and rank up and down. But fundamentally today is how do you provide the data to be found, right? Think of this as typical search engine optimization and Google, right, keyword. This is a bit more complex on your data structure. So maybe a long-winded answer, but hopefully that provides you a lot of food for thought on where the future is heading in my view. Great, great insight. We are getting some questions specifically about the study. I think we'll save those for your follow up. I encourage everyone who is watching. If you have, you know, if you want to get more granular into what was measured, definitely put them in the chat and they can follow up when this is closing, when this is concluded. I think we have time for just one last question. You know, you talked about keeping everyone up at night. Maybe we can send them off with just some actionable takeaways. So what is one move that you would share for a marketing leader they could make next Monday morning? That would really start moving the needle. What's your final words of advice? You know, I was thinking about this before, actually during the webinar, I mentioned a couple of things, you know, you should do right away. And, you know, it's not, I think, first of all, I think a little self-diagnosis is probably a great first step, you know, there were two different kind of litmus tests we mentioned. One is, Are you still measuring things like volume of emails and open rate? If not, if you are, you need to be thinking to the new measurements. And I think the other question was, are you campaign focused or are you more personalization and lifecycle focused? Really ask yourself those questions and think about what the implications would be if you want to move beyond this kind of like old world thinking. Ways of doing it. That would be, you know, a simple, simple homework, right? Guys, self-diagnosis and that hopefully will lead to some good action. Shady, any final thoughts? I'd say Monday morning, if you're a Head of Marketing, go for lunch with your Head of Service and just start connecting the dots. Pick one executive that you want to sit down to and align. How do we bring the business together? Again, the way to eat an elephant is one bite at a time. Take that first bite. Great. Well, definitely a great board to leave us with a great vision to leave us with. So I'm afraid that is all the time we have for today. So I have to go ahead and wrap things up. Sunny, Shady, I want to thank you so much for giving us your time, your subject matter expertise and insight into this report. I'd also like to thank SAP for sponsoring today's webinar. So just a reminder, a webinar recording will be available on demand shortly today on the PDPI, CGT and PG websites. You should receive an email about it. And so just finally, thank you to all of our attendees for giving us your time today. We hope you found it worthwhile, and keep a look out for more webinars from our brands. Have a great rest of your day. Thank you. Thank you, bye.

